N※N

Could 2023 See a "Golden Holiday Rally"?

72

  //stocks-investing.news-articles.net/content/2025/12/28/could-2023-see-a-golden-holiday-rally.html
  Published in Stocks and Investing on Sunday, December 28th 2025 at 10:31 GMT by Seeking Alpha

• 🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication
• 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source

Can History Repeat? Examining the Potential for a “Golden Holiday Rally” in 2023

The end of the year often brings a sense of optimism to financial markets, fueled by holiday cheer and a tendency for investors to look forward rather than dwell on past challenges. This has historically manifested as what's commonly referred to as a "Santa Claus Rally," but Seeking Alpha’s recent article, “Golden Holiday Rally,” suggests something potentially even more significant might be brewing – a confluence of factors pointing towards an unusually robust year-end surge. The article, authored by Michael Bagel, argues that the current market conditions bear striking similarities to those preceding historically strong holiday rallies, and outlines why investors should pay attention.

Understanding the Santa Claus Rally & Its Variations

Before diving into the specifics of a "Golden Holiday Rally," it's important to understand its predecessor. The Santa Claus Rally is generally defined as a period of positive market performance occurring during the last five trading days of December and the first two trading days of January. While not guaranteed, it’s a recurring phenomenon with a historically high success rate. Bagel notes that over the past 76 years (since 1948), the Santa Claus Rally has occurred in roughly 79% of those periods. The average gain during these seven trading days is around 1.3%.

However, Bagel posits that this year's potential rally could be more than just a typical Santa Claus event – hence the "Golden" descriptor. He argues that several key indicators suggest a larger move might be in store.

Key Factors Supporting a Strong Rally

The article highlights five primary factors contributing to the possibility of a Golden Holiday Rally:

1. Low Investor Sentiment: Investor sentiment has been consistently negative throughout 2023, driven by concerns about inflation, interest rate hikes, and recessionary fears. This pervasive pessimism often creates a contrarian environment where a market rebound can be surprisingly powerful as short-sellers cover their positions and sidelined investors cautiously re-enter the market. As Bagel points out, extreme negativity is frequently followed by positive surprises. The CNN Fear & Greed Index, referenced in the article, currently sits at "Fear," further reinforcing this point.

2. Falling Interest Rates (Anticipation): The Federal Reserve has signaled a potential shift towards easing monetary policy in 2024. While rate cuts aren't guaranteed and their timing remains uncertain, the expectation of lower rates is already impacting bond yields and creating a more favorable environment for stocks. Lower interest rates make borrowing cheaper for companies and reduce the attractiveness of bonds relative to equities.

3. Strong Corporate Earnings (Resilience): Despite widespread recessionary predictions, corporate earnings have largely held up better than expected. While growth may be slowing, many companies are demonstrating resilience in the face of economic headwinds. This suggests that the market's previous pessimism might have been overly harsh. Bagel references data showing that Q3 2023 earnings were surprisingly robust.

4. Tax-Loss Harvesting is Mostly Complete: Tax-loss harvesting – a strategy where investors sell losing positions to offset capital gains for tax purposes – typically occurs in November and early December, putting downward pressure on stock prices. Bagel argues that this activity has largely subsided, removing a potential headwind from the market.

5. Year-End Window Dressing: Portfolio managers often engage in "window dressing" at year-end, which involves selling underperforming assets and buying those with better performance to improve their portfolios' appearance for client reports. This can create artificial demand for stocks that have done well throughout the year, further boosting prices.

Historical Precedents & Potential Magnitude

The article draws parallels between the current market environment and previous periods that saw exceptionally strong holiday rallies. Bagel specifically references 1999 and 2009 as examples. In 1999, the dot-com boom was in full swing, and investor optimism was high (though ultimately unsustainable). In 2009, the market was emerging from the depths of the financial crisis. Both years saw significant year-end rallies.

While predicting the exact magnitude of a potential rally is impossible, Bagel suggests that based on historical data and current conditions, a gain exceeding the typical 1.3% is plausible. He doesn't offer specific price targets but emphasizes the importance of being prepared for a potentially positive surprise. He cautions, however, that unexpected negative news – such as a significant escalation in geopolitical tensions or a sharp deterioration in economic data – could derail the rally.

Caveats and Considerations

The article acknowledges that past performance is not indicative of future results. While the factors supporting a Golden Holiday Rally are compelling, they don't guarantee its occurrence. Furthermore, Bagel stresses the importance of maintaining a long-term investment perspective and avoiding impulsive decisions based solely on short-term market movements. He also notes that the S&P 500 is already trading at relatively high valuations, which could limit the potential for significant gains.

Conclusion: A Reason for Cautious Optimism

“Golden Holiday Rally” presents a compelling case for cautious optimism heading into the year-end. While risks remain and unforeseen events can always disrupt market trends, the confluence of low investor sentiment, anticipated interest rate cuts, resilient corporate earnings, completed tax-loss harvesting, and potential window dressing creates an environment conducive to a stronger-than-usual Santa Claus Rally. Investors should be aware of these factors and prepared for the possibility of positive surprises, while remaining mindful of the inherent uncertainties in financial markets. The article encourages investors to review their portfolios, consider their risk tolerance, and avoid making rash decisions based solely on short-term market fluctuations.

Note: I've tried to capture the essence of Bagel’s argument as presented in the Seeking Alpha article while adding some explanatory context for a broader audience. I also included references to linked content where relevant to provide further background and support the analysis.