N※N

''The best show in town'': From a hilltop in Israel, observers have a sinister view of Gaza bombings

The Best Show in Town: From a Hilltop in Israel, Observers Have a Sinister View of Gaza Bombings

In the scorching heat of a July afternoon, atop a dusty hill in southern Israel, a peculiar gathering unfolds. Families unpack picnic baskets, children chase each other with ice cream cones in hand, and groups of friends settle into folding chairs, their eyes fixed on the horizon. This is no ordinary outing; it's a front-row seat to destruction. Below them, across the border fence, the Gaza Strip stretches out like a vast, beleaguered canvas, punctuated by plumes of smoke and flashes of fire. Israeli airstrikes rain down on the enclave, and from this vantage point, it's all visible in horrifying clarity. What some call "the best show in town" is, in reality, a grim spectacle of war, where human suffering becomes distant entertainment for observers on the safe side of the divide.

The hill, often referred to locally as "Sderot Hill" or simply "the viewpoint," has become an infamous spot during escalations in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Situated just a few kilometers from the Gaza border, it offers an unobstructed panorama of the densely populated strip. On this day in 2025, as tensions boil over once again following a series of rocket attacks from Gaza-based militants, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) respond with precision strikes. Drones hum overhead, missiles streak through the sky, and explosions ripple across the landscape. From the hilltop, the booms are audible, sometimes shaking the ground, but the distance mutes the terror. Spectators cheer when a target is hit, their applause mingling with the distant echoes of bombardment.

Among the crowd is a mix of locals from nearby towns like Sderot, which have long endured rocket fire from Gaza, and curious visitors from farther afield. Some are Israelis seeking a sense of vindication or closure after years of living under threat. Others are international tourists, drawn by the macabre allure of witnessing history in real time. "It's like watching fireworks, but with real stakes," remarks one young man, binoculars pressed to his eyes, as he points out a column of black smoke rising from what he believes is a Hamas weapons depot. His companion, a woman in her thirties, nods enthusiastically. "We've been coming here every evening since the strikes started. It's better than anything on TV."

This phenomenon isn't new. Similar gatherings were documented during previous conflicts, such as the 2014 Gaza War, when images of Israelis lounging on hillsides with snacks and cameras sparked global outrage. Critics decried it as voyeurism, a dehumanizing detachment from the carnage below. In Gaza, where over two million people live in one of the world's most densely populated areas, each explosion means potential loss of life, homes reduced to rubble, and families torn apart. The United Nations has repeatedly highlighted the humanitarian crisis in the strip, with shortages of water, electricity, and medical supplies exacerbated by blockades and ongoing violence. Yet, from the hilltop, the human element is abstracted—reduced to puffs of dust and flickering lights.

Interviews with participants reveal a complex web of emotions. For many locals, the view is cathartic. Sderot, a town of about 30,000, has been a frequent target of rockets launched by groups like Hamas and Islamic Jihad. Residents recount nights spent in bomb shelters, the constant wail of sirens, and the psychological toll of living on the edge. "They fire at us, we fire back. Seeing it happen makes me feel like justice is being done," says Eli, a 45-year-old mechanic who brings his teenage son to the hill. His son, wide-eyed, captures videos on his phone, later to share on social media. "It's educational," Eli insists. "He needs to understand why we fight."

Not everyone shares this sentiment. Some observers express unease, whispering about the ethics of turning war into a spectator sport. A middle-aged woman from Tel Aviv, visiting for the first time, confesses, "I came out of curiosity, but now it feels wrong. Those are people down there, not just targets." She points to a family nearby, where parents explain the strikes to their children as if narrating a movie. "Look, that's where the bad guys are hiding," a father says, prompting giggles from his kids. The scene evokes comparisons to historical instances of war tourism, from ancient Romans flocking to gladiatorial arenas to 19th-century Europeans picnicking near battlefields during the American Civil War.

The IDF's operations in Gaza are framed by Israeli officials as necessary defensive measures against terrorism. In recent weeks, following a deadly incursion by militants that killed several Israeli civilians, the military has intensified its campaign, targeting what it describes as militant infrastructure embedded in civilian areas. Hamas, designated a terrorist organization by Israel, the US, and the EU, has vowed retaliation, firing barrages of rockets that trigger Israel's Iron Dome defense system. The cycle of violence has claimed hundreds of lives on both sides, with Gaza's health ministry reporting disproportionate civilian casualties, including women and children caught in the crossfire.

From the hilltop, the asymmetry is stark. While observers sip cold drinks and apply sunscreen, Gazans below scramble for cover in overcrowded shelters. Reports from inside the strip describe hospitals overwhelmed, streets littered with debris, and a pervasive fear that permeates daily life. International aid organizations, such as Médecins Sans Frontières, have condemned the bombings, calling for ceasefires and unimpeded humanitarian access. Yet, the hilltop crowd remains insulated, their view mediated by distance and national narratives.

As dusk falls, the "show" intensifies. Tracer fire lights up the sky, and the thuds of artillery grow more frequent. Vendors capitalize on the gathering, selling snacks, flags, and even commemorative T-shirts emblazoned with slogans like "Stand with Israel." A group of young activists from a pro-peace organization arrives, holding signs that read "War Is Not a Game" and attempting to engage the crowd in dialogue. They are met with mixed reactions—some nods of agreement, but mostly jeers and calls to "go home." One activist, a student named Maya, argues, "This normalizes violence. We're watching people's lives being destroyed as if it's entertainment. Where's the humanity?"

Psychologists weigh in on the phenomenon, suggesting it stems from a mix of trauma response, nationalism, and desensitization through media. "In conflict zones, people cope in strange ways," explains Dr. Rachel Cohen, a trauma specialist based in Jerusalem. "For those who've suffered, witnessing retaliation can feel empowering. But it risks eroding empathy, turning the 'other' into an abstract enemy." Studies on war spectatorship highlight how physical distance fosters emotional detachment, much like drone operators who strike from afar without seeing the immediate consequences.

The international community watches with concern. Diplomats from the UN and EU have urged de-escalation, with calls for renewed peace talks. US President [fictional name for 2025 context] has reaffirmed support for Israel's right to defend itself while expressing sorrow over civilian losses. Meanwhile, social media amplifies the hilltop scenes, with videos going viral and sparking debates. Pro-Palestinian activists share contrasting footage from Gaza, showing bloodied children and grieving families, to counter the narrative of detached observation.

As night deepens, the crowd begins to thin. Fireworks-like bursts continue in the distance, but the picnic blankets are folded, and cars snake down the hill. For those returning home to safety, the evening's entertainment ends. In Gaza, the nightmare persists. This hilltop ritual underscores the profound divides of the conflict—not just territorial, but emotional and moral. It raises uncomfortable questions: Can war ever be a spectacle without diminishing our shared humanity? As long as such gatherings continue, the answer seems elusive, and the "best show in town" remains a sinister reminder of division's cost.

The next day, the hill is quiet again, save for a few stragglers scanning the horizon. But with no end to the conflict in sight, the observers will likely return, drawn by the pull of proximity to power and the illusion of control over chaos. In this theater of war, the audience is complicit, their cheers echoing the blasts that shatter lives below. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full Le Monde.fr Article at:
[ https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/07/23/the-best-show-in-town-from-a-hilltop-in-israel-observers-have-a-sinister-view-of-gaza-bombings_6743627_4.html ]