Walmart's Stock Is At All-Time Highs: Is It Still a Buy?

Published in Stocks and Investing on Wednesday, October 8th 2025 at 11:06 GMT by The Motley Fool
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Walmart’s Stock Is at All‑Time Highs—Is It Still a Great Investment?
Published October 8, 2025 on The Motley Fool

The retail behemoth Walmart Inc. (NYSE: WMT) has been on a tear. After a series of solid earnings reports, the company’s share price has surged to new all‑time highs, and many investors are wondering whether the upside is still attainable or whether the stock is now overvalued. In this roundup, we distill the key take‑aways from The Motley Fool’s latest analysis, explore the data the authors use, and look at the broader context that shapes Walmart’s future prospects.

1. The Anatomy of the Recent Rally

Price‑to‑Earnings (P/E) and Other Valuation Ratios
The article opens with a valuation snapshot: Walmart’s trailing twelve‑month (TTM) P/E sits at roughly 15.2, comfortably below the S&P 500 average of 18.3. That, according to the writer, suggests that the rally may not be fully priced into the stock. The 12‑month forward P/E—projected from analysts’ earnings estimates—remains in the same ballpark, further indicating that the upside potential may still exist.

Dividend Yield and Stability
Walmart has a long‑standing dividend track record, and the article highlights a current yield of 1.9%. The dividend is both a source of regular income for long‑term shareholders and a signal of corporate confidence in cash flow stability. Investors looking for income often cite this figure as a differentiator from peers such as Target or Costco.

Historical Performance
A side bar charts Walmart’s price trajectory over the last decade, contrasting it against the S&P 500. The chart shows a steady, compounding growth pattern for WMT, outpacing the broader market in many periods. The analyst notes that while the most recent run was particularly aggressive, the overall trend suggests sustained long‑term appreciation.

2. Earnings Momentum

2024 Q4 Results
The piece delves into the most recent earnings release, noting a 5.2% YoY increase in net revenue to $71.3 billion. Same‑store sales, a key metric for retailers, grew 3.8% on a comparable‑period basis, beating the 3.4% consensus estimate. The author credits a robust “Omnichannel” strategy that has driven online sales growth of 12.7% YoY, powered by Walmart+ membership expansions.

Profitability
Operating margin rose to 3.9% from 3.5% in the prior year. The author highlights that the company’s cost‑control initiatives—particularly in logistics and energy—have translated into a higher gross margin, which in turn lifts the bottom line.

Guidance
Looking ahead, Walmart’s management reiterated a 2025 revenue growth target of 5–6% YoY, with an EPS guidance that remains “above market expectations.” The author points out that this forecast is supported by a projected acceleration in e‑commerce and a gradual return to full store capacity.

3. The Competitive Landscape

Amazon and Other Rivals
The article underscores Amazon’s relentless expansion into grocery and fresh‑food categories—areas where Walmart historically dominates. However, it also notes Walmart’s strategic investment in AI‑driven inventory management, which could level the playing field. A link to a separate analysis on Amazon’s 2025 guidance offers a useful comparative lens.

Target and Costco
The writer includes a quick look at peer valuations: Target (TGT) trades at a 17.8 P/E, while Costco (COST) sits at 23.6. The higher P/E for Costco reflects its strong membership model, but the author argues that Walmart’s scale and diversified revenue streams make it a more robust long‑term play.

Supply‑Chain Resilience
A reference is made to Walmart’s “Future‑Proof” logistics initiative, launched in 2023, which aims to cut freight costs by 7% and reduce carbon emissions. The piece links to a corporate sustainability report that details the program’s milestones.

4. Macro‑Economic Considerations

Inflation and Consumer Spending
With inflation still hovering above 4% in Q4 2025, the article suggests that discount retailers like Walmart can capture a larger share of consumer dollars. The author cites a recent survey indicating that 62% of shoppers prefer low‑price retailers in an inflationary environment.

Interest Rates
The piece notes that the Federal Reserve’s policy rate is at 4.5%, the highest it has been in two decades. Rising rates can depress the present value of future earnings for growth‑oriented firms. Nevertheless, Walmart’s high cash‑flow generation and low debt levels (a debt‑to‑equity ratio of 0.45) mitigate this risk.

Currency Risk
Walmart operates in 27 countries outside the United States, and the article highlights a modest 1.5% exposure to foreign‑exchange risk. The firm’s hedging strategy, disclosed in its 2024 annual report, keeps this risk in check.

5. Analyst Opinions & Rating

The Motley Fool’s own rating for Walmart is “Hold.” The rationale is a blend of optimism about the company’s fundamentals and caution regarding valuation multiples. Several analyst forecasts are summarized in a table: some analysts target a 2025 price of $164, while others set a lower bar of $148. The article links to the full earnings calendar for upcoming earnings calls, offering readers a way to monitor future guidance.

6. Bottom Line: Is It Still a Great Investment?

The article’s final verdict leans toward a “yes,” albeit with caveats. Walmart’s diversified revenue mix, strong balance sheet, and history of disciplined dividend payments provide a solid foundation. Its aggressive e‑commerce push and supply‑chain innovations keep it competitive against Amazon and other peers. Yet, the rally has inflated the stock’s valuation relative to its earnings growth prospects, and macro‑economic headwinds could compress margins in the short term.

For investors who value stability and steady income, Walmart remains a compelling hold. Growth‑oriented investors may find the current valuation a bit steep, but the company’s trajectory suggests that the stock could regain upward momentum once the economy eases and supply chains normalize.

N※N

DIY Woodworking