The Enduring Wisdom of Buy and Hold: Why Burt Malkiel Still Sees Meme Stocks as a Distraction

Published in Stocks and Investing on Saturday, August 23rd 2025 at 15:07 GMT by Business Insider
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Burt Malkiel, the legendary Princeton economist and author of "A Random Walk Down Wall Street," remains steadfast in his belief that passive investing is the superior strategy for most investors – even amidst the frenzy of meme stocks and speculative trading. In a recent interview with Business Insider, Malkiel reiterated his core principles, cautioning against chasing short-term gains and emphasizing the power of long-term, diversified investment through index funds and ETFs.

Malkiel's philosophy isn’t revolutionary; it’s rooted in decades of research demonstrating that consistently beating the market is extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible, for all but a tiny fraction of professional investors. His book, first published in 1973 and continually updated, has become a bible for those seeking a rational approach to investing, advocating for a “buy-and-hold” strategy that minimizes transaction costs and emotional decision-making.

The current market landscape, dominated by the rise and fall of meme stocks like GameStop and AMC, provides a stark illustration of Malkiel’s point. These companies experienced dramatic price swings fueled by coordinated retail investor activity on platforms like Reddit's WallStreetBets. While some early participants made substantial profits, many more lost money as the hype faded and prices plummeted. Malkiel views these events not as opportunities but as distractions from sound investment principles.

"It’s a fool’s errand to try to time the market or pick individual stocks," Malkiel stated plainly. He argues that attempting to predict short-term market movements is akin to trying to guess which way a tossed coin will land – it's essentially random. The meme stock phenomenon, he believes, exemplifies this folly, highlighting how easily emotions and social media trends can override rational analysis.

Malkiel’s preferred approach involves investing in low-cost index funds or ETFs that track broad market indexes like the S&P 500. This strategy provides instant diversification across hundreds of companies, reducing risk compared to concentrating investments in a few individual stocks. He emphasizes the importance of minimizing expenses – management fees and transaction costs – as these can significantly erode returns over time. As he points out, even small differences in expense ratios can compound into substantial losses over decades.

The rise of algorithmic trading and high-frequency trading (HFT) further reinforces Malkiel’s argument for passive investing. These sophisticated systems execute trades at lightning speed, exploiting tiny price discrepancies that are virtually invisible to individual investors. Malkiel acknowledges the role these technologies play in market efficiency but also notes they create a playing field where retail investors are inherently disadvantaged. Trying to compete with algorithms is a losing proposition.

He’s not entirely dismissive of active management; he recognizes that some skilled fund managers may outperform the market over certain periods. However, he stresses that consistently beating the market requires exceptional skill and luck – and even then, it's often short-lived. The vast majority of actively managed funds underperform their benchmark indexes after accounting for fees.

Malkiel’s perspective extends beyond just individual investors. He also expresses concern about the potential impact of speculative trading on overall financial stability. While he doesn't advocate for government intervention, he believes regulators should monitor these trends and ensure market integrity. The volatility surrounding meme stocks, he suggests, could be a warning sign of broader systemic risks.

Despite the constant evolution of financial markets and the emergence of new investment fads, Malkiel’s core message remains remarkably consistent: embrace simplicity, diversify broadly, minimize costs, and invest for the long term. He sees little value in chasing fleeting trends or trying to outsmart the market. Instead, he champions a patient, disciplined approach that prioritizes sustainable returns over short-term gains – a philosophy that has served investors well for decades and continues to offer a sensible path through the often-turbulent waters of the financial world. His advice isn't about getting rich quick; it’s about building wealth steadily and responsibly, avoiding the pitfalls of speculation and embracing the power of compounding over time.

N※N

The Enduring Wisdom of Buy and Hold: Why Burt Malkiel Still Sees Meme Stocks as a Distraction